5. Other Recordings - 1950s and later

These CDs feature recordings which were made (broadly speaking) in the 1950s or later.
Contents

Jerome Kern Songbook: Ella Fitzgerald
A joyous listen from start to finish. It's too bad that Ella did not explore more of the Kern treasurehouse. The glorious purity of her tone across the register delivers the gorgeous Kern melodies to perfection in these Nelson Riddle arrangements.

The four Fields entries are as follows:

The Way You Look Tonight I agree with liner note writer Dan Morgenstern when he complains that the tempo is just too slow in this arrangement.
A Fine Romance an extremely swinging fine romance, but the lyrics and the comic sarcasm come through.
Remind Me some find this to be Fields' best lyric, and there are few better versions than this.
You Couldn't Be Cuter the jewel of the collection, and not just because of its relative rarity. What'll they tell me? Exactly! colloquial Fields at her best. A disgraceful charm.

Fields tracks: A Fine Romance, I'll Be Hard To Handle, You Couldn't Be Cuter, Remind Me, The Way You Look Tonight


Lucky in the Rain
This is a great CD with a splendid cast and fine arrangements of Jimmy McHugh songs from Wally Harper.

Lucky in the Rain is one of those musicals fashioned around a score of old classic songs. Six of the songs have Fields lyrics; Harold Adamson is responsible for the rest. The show is set in 1920s Paris. Consequently in the show On The Sunny Side of the Street is sung by Gertrude Stein (to Alice T, of course), Doin' The New Low Down is sung by Josephine Baker, and Love Me As Though There Were No Tomorrow is sung by Isadora Duncan!

In fact in this studio recording, the singers do not correspond to the parts in the stage show � they play more than one character and share characters. Furthermore, apart from the afore-mentioned Love Me As Though There Were No Tomorrow (lyric by Adamson), the Barbara Cook numbers all come from her Close As Pages In A Book CD, recorded years earlier.

No matter, the songs are wonderfully performed � particular nice to have is Lillias White's sizzling rendition of Doin' The New Low Down.

Fields tracks: Exactly Like You, On The Sunny Side Of The Street, Doin' The New Low-Down, I Must Have That Man, Don't Blame Me, I Can't Give You Anything But Love


Yours For A Song - Here's to the Ladies: Peter Mintun
Peter Mintun has been playing piano in cabaret and clubs for decades, but has only recently turned to singing. The liner notes to this CD state : Peter is the first to admit he's no Luciano Pavarotti his friend Bobby Short once said of him He sings like a songwriter!. Well it's true that his voice is very unsure on the notes and has no range to speak of, but his diction is good, and he just about gets away with it.

The interest of this CD, dedicated to women songwriters, is in the rarity of its material. Interesting liner notes on the more obscure songwriters. The four Fields tracks are :
I Can't Give You Anything But Love clearly not a rarity.
Got A New Lease On Life one of the three Oscar Levant songs Dorothy wrote. This is the most interesting track, as the lyric is charming. Mintun has trouble with the complex Levant melody though.
Dinner At Eight written for but not used in the film of the same name. This is a sub-standard Fields lyric the dull phrases drag over the slow-paced melody, at least in this version.
Thank You For A Lovely Evening another dull lyric.
In conclusion, this recording is only for the completist collector.

Fields tracks: Dinner At Eight, I Can't Give You Anything But Love, Got A New Lease On Life, The Way You Look Tonight, Thank You For A Lovely Evening


Where Do I Go From You?: Philip Chaffin
This is the first CD from new label PS classics from producer Tommy Krasker.

Its sound is unique among recent recordings, because it recaptures the singer with the band style of big bands and dance bands of the 1940s. Chaffin's voice and control are vital ingredients in pulling this off, and the result's a delight throughout. He does a great Serenade in Blue.

The rare Fields item Where Do I Go From You? has a sweet, rueful lyric, and there are many other worthwhile discoveries from great songwriters. The original lyric for Too Marvelous For Words features a refrain we never hear now, and Mercer has some real fun with words in this version.

Fields tracks: Where Do I Go From You, The Way You Look Tonight


50 by Bobby Short: Bobby Short
This is a great collection by the supreme cabaret performer. Although only one Fields track features, it is a rarity one of the 3 songs she wrote with Oscar Levant.

Fields tracks: Don't Mention Love To Me


Songs of New York: Bobby Short
Another fine collection, this time including a jaunty rendition of a number from Sweet Charity.

Fields tracks: My Personal Property


Julie Wilson sings the Cy Coleman songbook: Julie Wilson
This is a highly enjoyable live recording of the celebrated singer in a cabaret performance at the Algonquin.

Those unfamiliar with her work may get a shock when they first hear Julie Wilson's voice - the ravaged, hollow sound is unlike that of any other cabaret performer, and tends to dull the Cy Coleman melodies on this disc. However this is amply compensated by her personality and the skill with which she delivers a lyric.

There are four Dorothy Fields songs on this recording. Two are familiar, and two are previously unrecorded. There is a cut song I Can't Let You Go from Sweet Charity, which covers much the same ground as the soul-searching songs for Charity which remained in the show. Then there is a joyous discovery in a song from Eleanor (not on the songlist in Deborah Grace Winer's book] called Do Be A Darling. The marvellously funny lyric is treated to a magnificent performance from Wilson, who adopts the character of a tipsy, drawling, selfish socialite demanding ever more outrageous favours from her friends. Wilson's wheedling archness and the vague airy tones in which she promises favours in return are priceless.

Fields tracks: I Can't Let You Go, Big Spender, Nobody Does It Like Me, Do Be A Darling


The Very Best Of Pat Suzuki: Pat Suzuki

Fields tracks: Just For Once, Two Faces In The Dark


Trav'lin' Light/Merely Marvelous: Mabel Mercer

Fields tracks: Merely Marvellous


Where, Oh Where: Judy Kaye

This wonderful CD is highly recommended. It contains a superb collection of unjustly neglected gems, beautifully interpreted by the versatile, pure-voiced Judy Kaye. The Fields track from Up in Central Park is delightful.

Fields tracks: Carousel In The Park


Like Someone in love: Ella Fitzgerald
A wonderful Fitzgerald collection. Lost in a Fog is beautifully mournful.

Fields tracks: Lost In A Fog


Fine & Dandy : Barbara Lea
Another grand old girl from cabaret, this time with a CD devoted to the work of women songwriters. There are four Fields tracks, and all are fine except for I Dream Too Much, which (contrary to the principle professed in the liner notes) she swings with.

Lost In A Fog has an introduction, and a middle section, which I have not heard elsewhere. Keith Ingham, her pianist, features prominently.

Fields tracks: I Dream Too Much, Blue Again, Lost In A Fog, Pick Yourself Up


Marni Nixon: Sings Classic Kern : Marni Nixon

Fields tracks: Lovely To Look At, The Way You Look Tonight, April Fooled Me, I Dream Too Much


Sugar Babies
The recording from the 1980s show starring Mickey Rooney and Ann Miller. I have not heard this recording.


Fields tracks: Don't Blame Me, I'm In The Mood For Love, Cuban Love Song, I Can't Give You Anything But Love


Randy Graff Sings Cy Coleman: Doing Something Right: Randy Graff


Randy Graff does some great versions of Carolyn Leigh numbers on this CD. She takes Big Spender at a slower pace than average, and successfully goes for insinuating rather than brassy. Not much of Nobody Does It Like Me survives in her Codependency Duet, but there is a rare performance of the title song from Seesaw. However she delivers it in much the same strident fashion as Michele Lee did on the OBC.



Fields tracks: Big Spender, Nobody Does It Like Me, Seesaw


Kern/Porter Favorites : Morton Gould Orchestra

Fields tracks: The Jockey On The Carousel, I Dream Too Much


Just For the Record: Barbra Streisand
This is a 4 CD set covering the history of Barbra Streisand's career with much interesting novelty material. The warmth, energy and humour of the earlier recordings are sadly missing in the assured but mechanical performances of today's Barbra.
A recording of the cut song You Wanna Bet from Sweet Charity is included.

Fields tracks: You Wanna Bet


Jeff Harnar Sings The 1959 Broadway Songbook: Jeff Harnar

Fields tracks: Look Who's In Love


Still Young & Foolish: Albert Hague
This is a recording of an "And then I wrote" show by Albert Hague, assisted by wife Renee Orin. I have not yet heard this disk.

Fields tracks: Erbie Fitch's Twitch


Emily Skinner & Alice Ripley: Duets: Skinner/Ripley



This is a very enjoyable CD from the formerly conjoined stars of Side Show. The version of Baby, Dream Your Dream is misguided however. It's a slow, dreamy, romantic arrangement. To try to make this work, they drop half of the supremely ironic lyrics, but the impact of the song is a fraction of the traditional delivery of the song - heavily sarcastic and mocking until the wistful twist at the end.

Fields tracks: Baby Dream Your Dream


Unforgettable: Johnny Hartman

Fields tracks: Today I Love Everybody


Verve Jazz Masters CD VOL. 51: Blossom Dearie
A splendid disc from a treasurable performer, but her departure into schoolgirl French during I Won't Dance does not improve the song.

Fields tracks: I Won't Dance


The Audience with Betty Carter: Betty Carter

Fields tracks: I'll Buy You A Star


Echo Of A Song : Ian Shaw

Fields tracks: just let me look at you


I'll Buy You A Star : Johnny Mathis

Fields tracks: I'll Buy You A Star


Alive/Rare Junk : Nitty Gritty Dirt Band

Fields tracks: Collegiana


Bennett & Basie : Tony Bennett

Fields tracks: Growing Pains


1. Collections


2. Cast Recordings


3. Other Recordings - Series


4. Other Recordings - up to 1940s






Dorothy Fields Website Home Page.......... Author : Jon Aldous...........